Showing posts with label Diversity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Diversity. Show all posts

Friday, October 30, 2009

Big D, little d, what begins with d?

When I was very young, (according to my son, when dinosaurs roamed the earth), I had a book entitled, "Dr. Seuss's ABC: An Amazing Alphabet Book!" It was one of my most favorite books and I remember the silly animals and items Dr. Seuss created to make an impression as to each letter of the alphabet.

Each alphabet character started with a new page and a new phrase. Something like this: "Big A, little a, what begins with A? Aunt Annie's alligator, A...a...A!" And so it went through the entire alphabet. It was silly, as only Dr. Seuss can be. It was hugely entertaining and somehow, learning surreptitiously insinuated itself amongst all the mirth and fun. Little did I realize, at such a tender age, my career in business would find another meaning for the phrase "Big D, little d, what begins with d?"

Some years later, (read 'a lot of years'), I was employed by a Fortune 500 company (not the one I am engaged with now), and they discussed the value of diversity as a means for competitive advantage. This organization divided diversity into two distinct groups: Big D and little d. The Big D represented protected classes. Those things, which to most of us, are obvious: Race, Creed, Color, Gender, Religion, etc. The little d represented those things which were not so obvious: Where you were raised (Midwest or Rocky Mountain West, urban or rural), where you went to school (Utah State University or Harvard, Trade School or higher education, high school or college degree), what you do with your spare time (watch TV or read a book, race a car or race to the store).

This organization taught and I personally agree with, the idea that the true value of diversity is getting past the Big D. That is not to say that the Big D is not important; it is. But that is like saying a wedding cake is important. Everyone at the wedding can see it and knows it's there. You can't really have a wedding without one. Comments abound on how it looks, the delicate floral frosting, the subtle colors and so forth. When people really get interested in the wedding cake is when it is cut. Does it have filling or not? If so, what kind of filling is it? Is it a white cake, yellow cake, chocolate cake, spice cake or some combination in layers? That's when the wedding crowd starts making the decision to take action on how big and how often they will have a piece of cake.

Diversity is the same. We need to get beyond the obvious. Doing so allows us to see what the real competitive advantages are. Reference my blog post about the IDEO company, (as well as any blog posts with the label "Diversity".) Any way, the IDEO company: they leveraged the little d and got fantastic results in what is now known as the shopping cart project. Investigative teams are the same way. It is the little d that truly delivers results.

The problem is that it is difficult and challenging to try and find the little d and what value it will have on the Investigation and the Investigative Team. Doing so requires discipline and forethought. Lead Investigators that exercise this type of deliberation, will have much more robust investigations. The risk of not understanding and leveraging the little d is Cognitive Myopathy.

So...Big D, little d, what begins with d?

A good, robust Investigation!

Tuesday, October 20, 2009

When The Lead Investigator Is Happy...

Yesterday, I was speaking with yet again, another colleague (I have a lot of colleagues!), and shared with her (we'll call her Christine, her real name is Christine), this concept of SMIs. Although I found the term intriguing myself, Christine really enjoyed it and was quite animated. Here, I believe, is why:
  1. If you acknowledge someone as an SMI, and you bring them into the investigative team as an SMI and if they embrace the idea of being an SMI, this has great potential to bring an air of fun and light-heartedness to the investigation. In my view, a sense of fun, makes what would otherwise be a tedious investigation, go much faster and more interesting.
  2. If the SMI understands clearly their role as such, then they will have the added value of being consciously critical, asking the difficult why's without fear or reservation.
  3. If the SMI is comfortable and has fun with their role on the investigative team, then you have clearly established a safe environment for the investigation to take place in.
Actually, all these points are indicative of a safe environment. Christine's animation about the SMI concept, is because she holds these three things in high esteem. She knows the value of a safe environment for an investigation, especially a difficult one.

One of the single most important aspects of an investigation, is that the environment IS safe for all the investigative team members. This allows for a forum where anyone can speak wit hout fear of judgment or repercussions outside the investigation. Especially SMIs. When team members can operate without fear, then ideas and interaction flow freely, accelerating the investigation.

This makes the Lead Investigator very happy. And you know what they say:

When the Lead Investigator is happy, everyone is happy!

(By the way. Today is my son's 20th birthday. He is in Spain and I haven't seen him since February 18th. So here is my message to him: ¡CumpleaƱos felices Lorin Douglas! )

Friday, October 16, 2009

Subject Matter Idiots

I was in yet another conversation, with yet another colleague, as we discussed the value of having someone who is not close to the process, to be on the investigative team. He is a Six Sigma Black Belt and told me that his group called these people SMIs. Like a goof, I asked what an SMI was and he responded, "Subject Matter Idiots."

We had a good laugh, but his point is well made. You want someone who knows nothing about the process being investigated. They are not afraid to ask questions that won't be asked by people who, because of their expertise, may not consider the question at all. Not because they are above the question, but because they are too close to the process, for the question to even be on their radar screen.

I like to think of this concept as a painting by Claude Monet, credited with starting the "Impressionist" era in art during the late 19th century. Monet used textured "dobs" of paint to create an impression of what was seen by the observer of the painting. Consider his work, "Sunflowers", a famous still of sunflowers in a vase on a table. If you were to get as close at this work as you physically could and look at it, all you would see were "dobs" of oil paint in rich yellows and oranges, with some greens, which made no apparent sense at all. But as you stand back, you can see the collection of color swaths come together to make sense of something meaningful to the eye of the observer.

Investigations are similar. Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) are too close to the process. Whereas an SME cannot see the broader view because of their Cognitive Myopathy, an SMI has no Cognitive Myopathy. Without such a filter, there are no rules and anything, or any question, is fair game.

I have been involved with investigations where SMIs took the investigation down the path to true Root Cause by asking the "why" questions no one else could see.

When you need a fresh perspective, don't be afraid to leverage a Subject Matter Idiot.

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Group Think is Thoughtless

In the 18th Century, the Vienna General Hospital had a serious problem. There was a high degree of infant deaths due to puerperal fever. Data for infant deaths became available in 1784. From 1784 to 1822 the infant mortality rate was about 2%. From 1823 to 1841 infant mortality was about 7% and from 1841 to 1846 it jumped yet again to nearly 10%.

Women plead not to be admitted unless they had to be, knowing their babies had just as good a chance at survival, outside the hospital as in. Physicians studied this phenomenon and could come up with no cause as to why. Doubly perplexing was that infants delivered by mid-wives had a mortality rate of 0.6% as opposed to the infants delivered by the physicians and medical students, which had the near 10% mortality rate.

In 1846 Dr. Ignaz Semmelweis agreed to a three year contract to work at the hospital, beginning that year. He became aware of the problem, pored over the data and learned that in 1823, pathological anatomy began at the medical school, where physicians and medical students would dissect and study cadavers. Midwives did not attend the medical school, and as such performed no pathological anatomy. The physicians and medical students would complete their anatomy classes and then attend to the obstetrics of the hospital, now being carriers of cadaverous contamination.

Upon recognizing this issue, Semmelweiz instituted the practice of hand washing in chlorine after a physician or medical student completed a pathological anatomy. This was instituted in 1847. Infant mortality rates from 1847 to 1858 were about 1.6%, significantly lower than the nearly 10% mortality rate before.

During the decades prior to the investigation of Semmelweiz, the physicians in the hospital could not begin to fathom that anything they were doing would be the cause of the increased infant mortality rates. This is a classic example of Group Think. Group Think is found in organizations (larger than one individual). Tunnel vision and myopathy are synonymous with group think, but can also apply to the individual.

I read a book once, entitled, "Leadership and Self-Deception: Getting Out of the Box," in which the example was given of an infant learning to crawl. The infant gets up on its hands and scoots around by pushing itself back. Eventually, it gets wedged against something and cannot scoot back farther, becoming trapped. Frustrated, it screams and cries and pushes back harder, but to no avail. The paradigm of the infant does not allow it to consider that it might be the source of its own problem. If it could see the problem, it may not be able to do anything, if much about it, because it may not have the capability to change direction without pushing back. Intervention is nearly always required.

This is the hallmark of Group Think, Tunnel Vision and Myopic thinking. That is why it is important to have the emotional maturity to allow someone else to challenge the thought processes we are engaged in. This is critical to a good investigation. Having someone on your investigative team who will challenge the process can get others to see and think about things in a different way. This is necessary to a robust and successful investigation.

Group Think is thoughtless.